|During the financial year, the Audit Committee carried out its duties and
responsibilities in accordance with its terms of reference and held
discussions with the internal auditors, external auditors and relevant
members of Management. The Audit Committee is of the view that no material
misstatements or losses, contingencies or uncertainties have arisen, based on
the reviews made and discussions held.
MEMBERSHIP AND TERMS OF REFERENCE OF THE AUDIT COMMITTEE
The Audit Committee is appointed by the Board of Directors from amongst the Non-Executive
Directors and consists of three (3) members, all of whom are Independent Non-Executive
The Chairman of the Audit Committee, Mr. Pushpanathan a/l S A Kanagarayar is a member
of the Institute of Chartered Accountants of Scotland, the Malaysian Institute of Certified
Public Accountants (MICPA) and the Malaysian Institute of Accountants (MIA). The other members
of the Audit Committee are Tan Sri Abdul Halim bin Ali and Datuk Ir. Hamzah bin Hasan.
MEETINGS AND MINUTES
Four (4) meetings were held during the financial year with the attendance of the Chief
Financial Officer, Head of Internal Audit, senior representatives of the external auditors and the
A quorum consists of two (2) members present and both of whom must be Independent
Directors. Other Board members and Senior Management may attend meetings upon the
invitation of the Audit Committee. Both the internal and external auditors, too, may request a
meeting if they consider that one is necessary.
During the financial year, the Chairman of the Audit Committee had engaged on a continuous
basis with relevant members of the Senior Management, Head of Internal Audit and the
external auditors, in order to keep abreast of matters and issues affecting the Group.
The Company Secretary acts as the secretary to the Audit Committee. Minutes of each
meeting are distributed electronically to each Board member, and the Chairman of the Audit
Committee reports on key issues discussed at each meeting to the Board.
Details of the Audit Committee members' attendance are tabled below:
AUTHORITY AND DUTIES
Click to view the terms of reference
of the Audit Committee.
REVIEW OF THE AUDIT COMMITTEE
An annual assessment and evaluation on the performance and effectiveness of the Audit Committee was undertaken
by the Board of Directors for the financial year ended 31 March 2016. The Audit Committee was assessed based on
four (4) key areas, namely effectiveness and quality, internal and external audit, risk management and internal control
and financial reporting, to determine whether the Audit Committee had carried out its duties in accordance with its terms
The Board is satisfied that the Audit Committee and its members have discharged their functions, duties and responsibilities
in accordance with the Audit Committee?s terms of reference.
SUMMARY OF ACTIVITIES FOR THE FINANCIAL YEAR
During the year, the Audit Committee carried out the
- Reviewed the quarterly financial results and announcements as well as the year end financial statements of
the Group, and recommended them for approval by the Board;
- In the review of the quarterly financial results and annual audited financial statements, the Audit Committee
discussed with Management and the external auditors, amongst others, the accounting principles and
standards that were applied and their judgement exercised on the items that may affect the financial results and
- Confirmed with Management and the external auditors that the Company?s and Group?s annual audited
financial statements have been prepared in compliance with applicable Financial Reporting Standards.
- Reviewed and approved the annual audit plan proposed by the internal auditors to ensure the adequacy of the
scope and coverage of work;
- Reviewed the effectiveness of the audit process, organisation structure, resource requirements (adequacy and
suitability) for the year and assessed the performance of the overall Internal Audit function;
- Reviewed the audit reports presented by the internal auditors on their findings and recommendations with
respect to system and control weaknesses. The Audit Committee then considered those recommendations
including the Management?s responses, before proposing that those control weaknesses be rectified and
recommendations for improvements be implemented;
- Reviewed significant whistle-blowing cases; and
- Reviewed the report on the verification of allocation of options and shares conducted by the internal auditors
in relation to the Employee Share Option Scheme and Employee Share Grant Scheme under the Long Term
Incentive Plan (?LTIP?) of the Company that it is in compliance with the criteria set out in the By-Laws of the LTIP,
that had been disclosed by the Company to the employees of the Group.
- Reviewed and endorsed the external auditors? audit strategy, audit plan and scope of work for the year;
- Exercised oversight over the relationship with the external auditors to ensure that their coverage is focused and
that suitable overlap with the work of internal audit is achieved;
- Reviewed the assistance given by the internal auditors to the external auditors;
- The Audit Committee deliberated on the external auditors? presentation of:
• the terms, areas of responsibility, associated duties and scope of the audit as set out in the external auditors?
• the overall work plan and fee proposal;
• the major issues that arose during the course of the audit and their resolution;
• key accounting and audit judgements;
• the unadjusted differences identified during the audit; and
• recommendations made by them in their management letters and the adequacy of management’s responses;
- Reviewed and approved the provision of non-audit services by external auditors that were agreed to prior to
their commencement of such work and confirmed as permissible for them to undertake, as provided under
the By-Laws of the Malaysian Institute of Accountants. The amount of external audit fees and non-audit fees
incurred for the financial year ended 31 March 2016 were as follows:
The non-audit services rendered included tax compliance and advisory services, review of transfer pricing
documentation, and accounting software (RAMCO System).
- The Audit Committee met with the external auditors twice during the year, without the presence of
management, to review key issues within their sphere of interest and responsibility. During the private session
with the external auditors, it was noted that there were no major concerns from the external auditors and
they conveyed that they had been receiving full cooperation from the Management and staff;
- Reviewed the external auditors report to the Audit Committee;
- Reviewed, assessed and monitored the performance, suitability and independence of the external auditors
pursuant to the External Auditors Policy (?the Policy?). The Audit Committee undertook an annual assessment
to assess the performance, suitability and independence of the external auditors based on, amongst others,
the quality of service, sufficiency of resources, communication and interaction, as well as independence,
objectivity and professional skepticism. The external auditors provide an annual confirmation of their
independence in accordance with the terms of all professional and regulatory requirements.
Pursuant to the Policy, the engagement and concurring partners responsible for the Group audit are rotated
at least every five (5) financial years.
Following the review of the external auditors? effectiveness and independence, the Audit Committee is satisfied
with the performance and the audit independence of the external auditors. Accordingly, it was recommended
to the Board to re-appoint PricewaterhouseCoopers as auditors of the Company as well as the proposed audit
fee for approval. A resolution for their re-appointment will be tabled for approval at the forthcoming Annual
Risk Management Committee
- Reviewed the Risk Management Committee?s reports, assessed the adequacy and effectiveness of the risk
management framework and the appropriateness of Management?s responses to key risk areas and proposed
recommendations for improvements to be implemented.
Related Party Transactions
- Reviewed the related party transactions that arose within the Group to ensure that the transactions are fair and
reasonable, and are not to the detriment of, the minority shareholders.
During the year, all the Audit Committee members
have attended various seminars, training programmes
and conferences. Click to view Audit Committee members profile.
INTERNAL AUDIT FUNCTION
The Group?s Internal Audit function is carried out by the Internal Audit Department (?IAD?) that reports directly to the
Audit Committee. The internal auditors have direct access to the Audit Committee and the Chief Executive Officer &
Managing Director. The Audit Committee is satisfied that the internal auditors? independence have been maintained
as adequate safeguards are in place. All internal auditors had signed the annual declaration that they were and had
been independent, objective and in compliance with the Code of Ethics and Conduct of IJM Corporation Berhad and
The Institute of Internal Auditors in carrying out their duties for the financial year. The Audit Committee remained satisfied
that the Internal Audit function had sufficient resources during the year to undertake its duties.
The Internal Audit function provides to the Board (primarily via the Audit Committee) and to management reasonable
assurance on the effectiveness of the Group?s systems of internal control and the adequacy of these systems to manage
business risks and to safeguard the Group?s assets and resources.
The IAD is governed by the Internal Audit Charter and it sets out the purpose, functions, scope and responsibilities of
the Internal Audit function and how it maintains independence from the first and second line of defense by management
of the Group. The four main functions of Internal Audit are to:
- Assess and report on the effectiveness of the design and operation of the controls framework which enable risks to be
assessed and managed;
- Assess and report on the effectiveness of management actions to address deficiencies in the controls framework;
- Investigate and report on cases of suspected employee fraud and malpractice, if any; and
- Undertake designated advisory services for management provided that they do not threaten the function?s actual or
perceived independence from management.
The Internal Audit Plan for 2015-2016 was reviewed and approved by the Audit Committee in February 2015. Planned
reviews reflected the priorities in the Group?s 2015-2016 Operational Plan and were prioritised following a risk-based
assessment of the business and a review of the Group?s risk policies. The reviews carried out covered an extensive
sample of controls over all risk types, business units and entities.
The IAD adopts a risk based auditing approach, prioritizing audit assignments based on the group?s business activity,
risk management and past audit findings. It evaluated the adequacy and effectiveness of key controls in responding to
risks within the organisation?s governance, operations and information systems, in terms of:
- Reliability and integrity of financial and operational information;
- Effectiveness and efficiency of operations;
- Safeguarding of assets; and
- Compliance with relevant laws, regulations and contractual obligations.
All internal control deficiencies were reported to the appropriate levels of management when identified. The Audit
Committee received quarterly reports from the IAD on audit reviews carried out, management?s response to the
findings and progress in addressing identified issues. The management members were made responsible for ensuring
that corrective actions on reported control deficiencies were taken within the required timeframes. IAD conducted
follow-up audits on key engagements to ensure that the corrective actions were implemented appropriately.
In this respect, IAD has added value by enhancing the governance, risk management and control processes within
The Audit Committee reviewed and approved the IAD?s financial budget and human resource requirements to ensure
that the function is adequately resourced.
A range of initiatives are being developed, in particular the proposal for the procurement of audit management and
data analytics software, to increase the efficiency and effectiveness of the function?s audit management process and
data analytics capabilities. This proposal was presented to and approved by the Audit Committee, for implementation
in the financial year ending 31 March 2017.
The total cost incurred in managing the IAD for the financial year under review was approximately RM4.8 million
(FY2015: RM3.2 million).
A summary of internal audit cost distribution is as follows:
INTERNAL AUDIT ACTIVITIES FOR THE FINANCIAL YEAR
During the financial year, the IAD had completed and reported eighty-five (85) audit assignments covering the
construction, property, industry, infrastructure and plantation divisions, as well as the overseas operations of the
Group and functional audits of Group Support Services. The assignments included special audits requested by the
Board, Audit Committee or Senior Management, and those which arose from reports pursuant to the Group?s
The IAD, during the financial year, provided internal audit services to IJM Plantations Berhad. In an effort to provide
value added services, it also plays an active advisory role in the review and improvement of existing internal controls
within the Group.
Currently, the IAD comprises twenty-three (23) auditors with approximately 44,000 available man-hours per annum.
IJM is a Corporate Member of The Institute of Internal Auditors Malaysia.